Netflix’s new historical fiction series “American Primeval” is stirring controversy for its portrayal of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) and its leader Brigham Young.
Last Friday, the Mormon Church released a statement sharply criticizing the depiction presented in the series, calling it “dangerously misleading” and stating that Brigham Young’s characterization as a “fanatical villain and violent figure” is a blatant historical distortion.
“A recently released streaming series presents a fictional interpretation of events in mid-19th century Utah. While historical fiction can be enlightening, this drama is dangerously misleading,” the church stated. “Brigham Young, a revered prophet and courageous pioneer, is, by any historical standard, flagrantly mischaracterized. Other individuals and groups are also depicted in ways that reinforce stereotypes that are inaccurate and harmful.”
The Controversial Historical Depiction
Created by Peter Berg (“Friday Night Lights”) and written by Mark L. Smith, “American Primeval” follows the journey of a mother and son as they face the challenges of a harsh American West filled with freedom and cruelty. The cast includes Taylor Kitsch (Isaac), Elizabeth “Betty” Gilpin (Sara Rowell), Preston Mota (Devin Rowell), and Shawnee Pourier (Two Moons).
The show portrays historical events, including the Mountain Meadows Massacre during the Utah War (1857-58). In this episode, members of a territorial militia associated with the LDS Church killed 120 western American emigrants. The church criticized the series for “misrepresenting” the massacre as reflective of an entire religious group.
“The series presents a fictional and inaccurate portrayal of events, distorting historical understanding and damaging the reputation of our faith and pioneers,” the statement reads.
Debate on Historical Fiction
“American Primeval” blends historical facts with fictional storytelling, which, according to the church, reinforces harmful stereotypes. The series also explores conflicts among Indigenous nations, the U.S. government, westward-bound pioneers, and the emerging Mormon Church, including its Nauvoo militia.
The debate surrounding the series reflects a broader dilemma about how historical fiction should balance historical accuracy with creative freedom, particularly when addressing sensitive topics.
Sources: churchofjesuschrist / usatoday. This content was created with the assistance of AI and reviewed by the editorial team.
